Bringing No Answers To The Table
The New Strategy For Human Resources
It's been nearly 20 years since I attended a Human Resources conference in which the grand rallying cry was "turning HR into a strategic business partner." Recently, I attended another Human Resources conference and saw a show of hands revealed that the same issue was still on the mind of the participants. I wondered how much progress has Human Resources made in assuming that leadership position. The answer, although dismaying, contains a silver lining: the future is brighter than the statistics would indicate.
First, some bad news. In a recent survey of HR professionals, only 20 percent identified themselves as strategic partners. (That is up from a similar survey from 10 years ago.). Moreover, as many can attest, HR has also suffered from the realignment and outsourcing of services – one of the few "growth sectors" where HR is concerned. Taken together, we can predict that many of the roles HR plays in today's organizations could be replaced or outsourced in the near future.
And yet, the demand for what HR can provide has only gotten bigger. To answer the call, HR leadership has to establish its ability to connect the people side of the business with the operating strategy of doing business. This chasm is viewed myopically by most business leaders who have a tendency to be isolated in their various silos. Only HR has the inclination, let alone the capability, to energize business strategy across the organization by ensuring that the right people are in the right roles at the right time.
Why hasn't HR assumed that leadership role yet? If we consider the duties that HR has traditionally covered within the organization, we get a sense of where we have come from and where we need to go.
Human Resources grew out of Personnel. The primary role that Personnel filled in the organization was soliciting interview candidates, attending dismissal meetings, filling out paper work, hearing grievances and seeing that compensation was dispersed as promised. Personnel might have been involved in some training work, but that was mostly left to training professionals, and the training itself would have been focused on technical skills.
The field of Organizational Development, to which Human Resources now aspires, is a relatively "young" idea. Many of its fathers and original teachers are still active researchers and passionate advocates, some of them fresh and insightful, others sounding a bit like broken records. Even so, as the new kid of the block, OD has not been embraced or supported by many companies until relatively recently.
HR has talked the mission of the OD function but walked the tradition of Personnel. In order to serve business leaders like a good cost center should, HR has provided a sense of comfort to the organization that it is taking care of its people, by supplying a sense of humanity and empathy, while making sure that decision makers don't do any of the illegal employment practices that might land people in jail. Put in this passive role, HR still waits for its phone to ring, and it is quick to kow tow to the CFO whenever he screams for cost reductions.
Don't believe that the situation is really so grim? Then think about the power of the language associated with the HR function. Often, when I speak to business leaders about people issues, I talk disparagingly about the way HR handles its role. I'll say something like, "succession planning is not a bunny kissing, tree hugging, touchy feely endeavor, but a critical business concern." Heads in the room will nod, and a different level of dialogue will result. It's as though those business people are thinking to themselves: "Here's someone who's not going to make us sing Cumbaya for a change." Together, we role up our sleeves and get to work to define the tough business challenges facing the organization and how we are going to meet those needs.
What I don't bring to such meetings are pre-set answers. Business leaders do not want pre-packaged view points that don't address real issues. They want outsiders to have fresh perspectives which challenge their thinking and help them to see. The answer is in not having any answers! I often picture the traditional personnel or HR manager as analogous to the fabled Maytag Repairman waiting for the phone to ring. When the executive suite finally calls and says, "We need this now!" HR is only too eager to please. In fact, that is not how a real business leader operates. A strategic partner worth his or her salt approaches the executive like an equal, armed with experience and perspective, to apply thought and feedback to the problems of the day, in order to build the organization's capability for tomorrow.
Pushing back, challenging view points, being willing to bring no answers to the table – these are not behaviors which HR finds familiar or comfortable. But those are the mature skills which HR needs to adopt. By asking questions and not having pre-set answers, we engage others in reflective or creative dialogue. What is the impact of this strategy on the organization, and what kind of people are needed to deliver on it? How does the activity fit our corporate culture? What would be the result if we looked at this alternative? Thinking like a business leader whose own results are at stake can help the HR manager become a real partner.
In the final analysis, HR must look at itself with a positive perspective using positive words that move the business to a higher level. To assume its position at the strategic executive table, HR must:
Ask questions and stop having immediate answers.
Continue to push the dialogue until the next level of answer is discovered.
Develop processes and programs that demonstrably impact the following areas:
Ensure that people in the organization have a clear line of sight to the values and vision.
Learn how to say No
Ask the question Why – What will this do for the organization a year from now that is not happening today?
To get into the game, HR must learn to speak and think like a business person charged with making strategy operational. HR must have the courage to ask: "Have we considered this…?" Answering the call of the business doesn't mean doing what the business wants – it means doing what the business really needs. When that happens, the business will call on HR in a different way.